Psychology Reader

Emotional Experience Improves With Age: Evidence Based on Over 10 Years of Experience Sampling

Laura L. Carstensen, Bulent Turan, Susanne Scheibe, and 5 others · 2011 · Psychology and Aging

Role
Landmark empirical study
Difficulty
Moderate
Full work length
13 pages
Type
Journal article

Access

Psychology Reader links to legitimate sources and does not host article PDFs.

Reading focus

Syllabus: How Do We Adapt as We Grow Older?

Compare the preceding theory with what repeated reports of daily feelings can establish. Examine change within people, selective retention, and the gap between an age pattern and its explanation.

A question to consider. If emotional experience improves over repeated observations, which additional measures would help test whether changing time horizons and social priorities contribute?

Why this reading

A difference between younger and older adults need not describe what happens as a person ages. This study repeatedly samples everyday emotions and returns to participants over a decade. It offers a concrete opportunity to examine how a developmental claim changes when the evidence includes change within people.

Before you read

Experience sampling asks people to report experiences repeatedly in daily life. A longitudinal wave is a round of measurement separated from earlier rounds. Attrition is the loss of participants; refreshment samples add participants later. A model’s adjustment for measured differences cannot remove every source of selection.

Read for

  1. Distinguish emotional balance, variability, and the coexistence of positive and negative feelings. Which outcome supports each claim?
  2. Track the repeated participants and the additional samples across waves. Ask what the design can separate and what participant loss could change.
  3. Compare the observed age patterns with explanations involving goals, health, and circumstances. Which mechanisms does this study actually test?

Consider afterwards

  1. People who remain in a ten-year study report better emotional well-being than those who leave. What information would help you judge whether an apparent improvement reflects aging or selective retention?

Editorial context

The title summarizes patterns in a particular sample; it is not a promise that every person’s emotional life improves. The authors discuss sampling and attrition limits. Their emotional-experience association with mortality was no longer significant after accounting for initial physical health, so it should not be treated as evidence that positive emotion causes longer life. The study also does not directly establish the mechanism proposed by socioemotional selectivity theory.