Psychology Reader

The Good School Toolkit for Reducing Physical Violence from School Staff to Primary School Students: A Cluster-Randomised Controlled Trial in Uganda

Karen M Devries, Louise Knight, Jennifer C Child, and 11 others · 2015 · The Lancet Global Health

Role
Landmark empirical study
Difficulty
Moderate
Full work length
9 pages
Type
Journal article

Access

Psychology Reader links to legitimate sources and does not host article PDFs.

Reading focus

Syllabus: Why Do People Harm Others—and What Can Reduce It?

Compare this primary outcome and adult–child power relationship with the peer-network intervention. Track both the difference between groups and the harm that remains.

Why you’re reading it. Evaluate a prevention package using evidence close to the intended outcome while retaining limits on mechanism and transfer.

A question to consider. Before extending the Toolkit to another district, what evidence would you seek about implementation, sustained effects, reporting, and children who remain exposed to violence?

Why this reading

Prevention must be evaluated against the harm it intends to reduce. This trial studies a school-wide intervention where adults hold power over children, using students' reports of staff violence as its primary outcome.

Before you read

Schools, rather than individual students, were randomized. Repeated cross-sectional surveys sample students at each assessment instead of following the same children throughout. The Toolkit combines activities, support, and changes in school practices. An odds ratio is not a percentage reduction in risk.

Read for

  1. Trace assignment, implementation, and outcome measurement across the 42 schools.
  2. Compare the absolute prevalence of reported violence with the odds ratio and its uncertainty.
  3. Examine reporting, unmasked participation and data collection, continued harm, and the outcomes that did not clearly improve.

Consider afterwards

  1. Can this design tell whether empathy, alternative discipline, or another component caused the change?
  2. What follow-up would test durability after outside support ends?

Editorial context

Reported past-week staff violence was lower in intervention schools, but remained common. The trial tests the intervention package in one Ugandan district, not each proposed mechanism or every setting. It does not establish lasting effects, effects outside school, or improvements in all educational and mental-health outcomes. Its legal background describes the study period.