Psychology Reader

What Counts as Successful Implementation?

Enola Proctor, Hiie Silmere, Ramesh Raghavan, and 5 others · 2011 · Administration and Policy in Mental Health and Mental Health Services Research

Role
Foundational argument · Methodological contribution
Difficulty
Moderate
Full work length
12 pages
Type
Journal article

Access

Psychology Reader links to legitimate sources and does not host article PDFs.

Reading focus

Syllabus: How Can Effective Psychological Care Reach More People?

Specify the stakeholder, practice and time point behind each proposed implementation outcome.

Why you’re reading it. Distinguish delivering an intervention successfully from establishing its health benefit.

A question to consider. A service reports high staff satisfaction and more referrals. Which implementation and clinical outcomes are still missing?

Why this reading

A beneficial intervention and a workable implementation strategy answer different questions. Proctor and colleagues supply a vocabulary for examining whether a service can adopt and sustain a practice.

Before you read

Implementation outcomes concern introducing and maintaining a practice. Service outcomes concern care quality; clinical outcomes concern people’s health. These can be related without being interchangeable.

Read for

  1. Distinguish acceptability, appropriateness and feasibility rather than treating approval as proof a programme can be delivered.
  2. For each proposed outcome, specify whose perspective, which practice and what time point are being measured.

Consider afterwards

  1. A clinic adopts a programme that staff value but cannot maintain after funding ends. Which outcomes differ?
  2. What evidence would connect improved implementation with better patient outcomes?

Editorial context

The eight-outcome taxonomy emerged from a narrative review and working-group deliberation. It is a conceptual proposal and research agenda, not a demonstration that all proposed pathways hold. A 2023 scoping review found that tests linking implementation strategies, implementation outcomes and health outcomes remained limited.