Psychology Reader

Working Class Growing Pains

Jennifer M. Silva · 2014 · Contexts

Role
Critical reappraisal
Difficulty
Accessible
Full work length
6 pages
Type
Journal article

Access

Psychology Reader links to legitimate sources and does not host article PDFs.

Reading focus

Syllabus: How Do We Develop in Early and Middle Adulthood?

Use these accounts to examine the opportunities assumed in the opening theory. Distinguish uncertainty arising from exploration from uncertainty produced by insecure work, resources, or support.

A question to consider. How could two people with the same employment status have very different opportunities to explore a future?

Why this reading

Delayed milestones can have different meanings depending on the opportunities available. Silva's account connects young adults' interpretations of their lives with insecure work, education, relationships, and institutional support. It brings qualitative evidence into a debate often framed by average ages.

Before you read

An interview can reveal how a person understands an experience without establishing how common that account is. Structural explanations concern arrangements such as employment conditions and access to resources. Distinguish the interviewee's interpretation from the researcher's explanation.

Read for

  1. Identify where a participant's account supports an interpretation and where the author makes a broader claim.
  2. Compare the meaning of self-reliance across the examples.
  3. Ask what evidence would connect institutional conditions to changing commitments over time.

Consider afterwards

  1. Two people postpone moving out, one to explore careers and one because rent is unaffordable. What would a survey recording only their living arrangement miss?

Editorial context

This short Contexts feature reports on interviews with 100 working-class young adults; it is not a full methods report or a representative prevalence survey. Its accounts illuminate particular U.S. circumstances. They should not become a single portrait of a class, generation, or racial group. The longer 2012 research article develops the identity argument in greater depth.